The Milk Pail's u-pick farm on Horsemill Lane in Water Mill grows more than twenty kinds of apples and over 60 kinds of pumpkins, squash and gourds. In 2026 it is open every weekend from Labor Day weekend through Halloween weekend, weather permitting.
When can we pick?
Fridays, Saturdays and Sundays from 10 AM to 5:30 PM, and also on Columbus Day, Monday, October 12. No reservations are needed. Check the farm's announcements before you go, since it posts weather closures there.
How much are tickets?
Picking bag tickets are $32 cash for a peck bag, which admits 4 people, and $56 cash for a half bushel bag, which admits 6. Paying by card adds about 5%, so the peck is $33.60 and the half bushel $58.80. A peck holds 20 to 25 apples and a half bushel 40 to 50. Wagon tour tickets are $6 each.
How are pumpkins sold?
Pumpkins, gourds and squash are sold by the piece, in sizes from minis to more than 150 pounds.
Is it easy for little kids to pick?
Yes. The apple trees are dwarf trees, a good height for all ages. Stay out of roped-off areas, where apples are still ripening.
Is there anything else to do?
Farm wagon tours run during the u-pick season. Coffee, hot cider and treats are sold at the farm market, which also carries pies, cakes and muffins. The market is at 1346 Montauk Highway and is open every day except Tuesday.
Can we bring the dog?
No. Because of food safety rules, dogs and other pets are not allowed on the farm. Parking is free inside the fenced area. For photo shoots, ask the farm first.

